Northern Tanzania Maasai Land Loss Threatens Indigenous Knowledge 04/11/2015 by Fredrick Nzwili for Intellectual Property Watch 8 Comments Share this:Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)Click to print (Opens in new window)NAIROBI, Kenya – After a five year gruelling court battle, the indigenous Maasai community in Northern Tanzania has lost the right to its traditional land after the High Court handed it to a US-based tourism company in a court ruling on 27 October. The company, Thomson Safari, is developing a tourism site and a wildlife conservation area on the 10,000 acre land, but now this has put at stake the main source of livelihood and indigenous knowledge for the indigenous and semi-nomadic people, warn community leaders, lawyers and minority rights experts. The Maasai have retained most of their traditions and customs even as modernity creeps into most African communities. For their distinctive customs and symbolic dressing styles, their images are often used by Kenya and Tanzania to promote tourism. Yet, the ruling by the Arusha-based court appears to cast a dark shadow on this bright side of the community. “Generally, when land is taken away, it interrupts the people’s way of life. Land holds important customs and traditions and indigenous knowledge such as medicine. When it is taken way, a situation where the indigenous knowledge can be lost is created,” Rashid M. Rashid, the Maasai community lawyer in the case, said in an Interview. Pastoralism is an integral part of Maasai culture, as well as their livelihoods, and anything that erodes pastoralism means that the Maasai lose touch with their culture, adds Mohamed Matovu, Africa Regional Information Officer at Minority Rights Group International (MRG). “They may be forced to move to the city to find work, for example, and this means loss of indigenous knowledge, which is deeply linked to the natural world,” the official said. Affected are residents of Mondorosi, Sukenya and Soitsambu villages Loliondo district. They had sued the Tanzania Conservation Limited (TCL) and the government-owned Tanzania Breweries Limited (TBL) in 2010 over the ownership of the land. TCL has the same ownership as the Thomson Safaris, the US-based tourism company which is a division of Wine-land Thomson Adventure, based in Massachusetts, according MRG. The community had asked the court to revoke the company’s land title, prevent TCL from converting the land’s designated use from pastoralism to tourism, and award damages for the injuries they have suffered following their exclusion from the land. Impact on Traditional Medicines As the company takes control of the land, community members say important water sources and plants which the Maasai have used for decades extract traditional medicine will be inaccessible or lost. This is together with the space the land has provided for cultural practices such a circumcisions or passage of the age sets from Morans to young adults. With the grazing land gone, its means traditional knowledge of animal diseases and their treatment widely linked to their activities will also disappear. “The land is central to the community’s livelihood. Without access to the water wells on the land which we have used for years, I am not sure how the community will survive,” said Joshua Makko, an elder who has been involved in the case. “The loss of indigenous knowledge such as traditional medicine that is found in the plants growing there cannot be underestimated,” he added, citing roots used with soup to treat mothers who have delivered as one of the examples. The origin of the dispute can be traced back in 1994, when TBL acquired the land on the borders of the villages for growing wheat and barley. The company used only 700 acres and life continued normally for community, with people continuing to graze their animals, while accessing water from wells there. But in 2006, things changed when TBL sold the leasehold to Thomson Safari. The company started developing the land as a wildlife conservation area and tourist site while evicting the community. This sparked off protests during which the community claims their homes were razed with the residents being beaten and detained. Others have been shot at for trying to use the land and water at or near the contested land. “It is a significant defeat for the Maasai of Loliondo, who depend on raising and herding cattle in this harsh environment to earn their fragile living, and have had their main means of survival jeopardized by both international investors and their own government,’ said Lucy Claridge, MRG’s Head of Law in a statement. Maasai IP The latest ruling comes as the Maasai continue to battle for the legal rights on their name following the wide use by corporations to brand their businesses. The Maasai have been asking for a share in the profits that have accrued after their name helped grow the businesses. According to Ron Layton, founder of LightYears IP, a non-profit organisation dedicated to alleviating poverty by assisting communities gain ownership of their intellectual property, between 40 – 50 companies are still using the Maasai brand. LightYears IP says on its web that about 1000 companies have used the Maasai imagery to promote their products because associating a consumer product with the Maasai increases sales. “There were a lot of companies that had been using the name Maasai with their brands without the approval of the community, but many have since stopped,” said Layton, whose organisation has worked with the Maasai in Kenya and Tanzania to establish the Maasai Intellectual Property Initiative (MIPI). The indigenous organisation of elders and leaders has been seeking to unite the Maasai people to take control their cultural brand. According to Layton, initially there was no single organisation that represented all the Maasai and that made it difficult for them to claim the right to their name. Still, the current organisation represents only a small number of the community estimated at about 3 million. Asked if the Maasai will finally gain from the use of their brand by the companies, Layton said: “I am sure some revenue will come one day, but it will take a lot of hard work and representation.” Still, there is a challenge for the Maasai: There is no intellectual property right which specifically protects the cultural identity of an ethnic group or national group. Image Credits: Fredrick Nzwili Share this:Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)Click to print (Opens in new window) Related Fredrick Nzwili may be reached at info@ip-watch.ch."Northern Tanzania Maasai Land Loss Threatens Indigenous Knowledge" by Intellectual Property Watch is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Susanna Nordlund says 04/11/2015 at 5:16 pm TBL acquired the land in 1984 (not 1994) and had left by the 90s. A clear case of adverse possession. This not unexpected injustice will be appealed, and unbelievable rabid tour operator will spend any amount of money to keep their violent prestige project – but Thomson Safaris have to be stopped! Reply
live2saildestiny says 06/11/2015 at 2:38 pm As an American I abhor what Thompson is doing to displace these Maasai. It is wrong headed regardless of what the courts have ruled is “legal” it is just not right. I hope they are not successful in this take over to further their ‘profits’ from tourism. Reply
Aleja Orozco (@ResearchImpacts) says 09/11/2015 at 12:42 pm What a most sad development! the whole system is useless to pursue justice! We all need to move to stop all these injustices being perpetrated against indigenous peoples! Reply
palisep ngorongoro says 11/11/2015 at 9:13 am I understand there are comes the time when community interest are more important than individual, We know the case and the whole process was so corrupted just because masai community can afford to pay the lawyers to work towards this case. God can not be corrupted and I know Thomson safari’s days are numbered to vacate from Masai Land. Reply
Pure Maasai says 12/11/2015 at 11:53 am Thomson Safaris have know that this is not the end of the game, Masai community will ensure their land will come back for their coming generation. I am really very disappointed for this land grabbing tourism company that come from the world respected country America. Reply
Thomas Michael Mbeyela says 21/11/2015 at 1:18 pm I URGUE THE GOVERNMENT OF TANZANIA TO ENTERVENE THE SITUATION FOR HOW LONG THE MAASAI WILL CONTINUE TO BE MARGINALIZED EVACUTING EVERY CORNER LET THE PASTORALIST ENJOY THEIR RIGHT – TANZANIA IS OURS NOT FOR FORIGNERS. Reply
Fred Watkins says 23/11/2015 at 5:46 pm What I don’t understand is how to reconcile ‘land grabbing’ type of verbiage with Thomson Safaris’ legal ownership of the land. If they own the title free and clear, how is it Thomson Safaris’ fault? They own the land, they get it use it as they see fit. Reply
[…] action by the courts in Tanzania in favor of a tourism company offering safaris is presented as harming traditional […] Reply